Pumpkin is in 63% of Thanksgiving pie orders, but regional pies like sugar cream and marionberry stand out
Pumpkin was in 63% of Thanksgiving-week grocery orders that included a pie, Instacart's Thanksgiving Pie Report finds. Apple (23%), pecan (14%) and sweet potato (7%) followed, but regional standouts are sharp: Indiana orders sugar cream pie at about 58 times the national rate, Oregon and Washington lean marionberry, and French silk is the standout in Minnesota, Kansas, Illinois and Missouri. The analysis uses Thanksgiving-week 2025 orders.
Why it matters for directors: Pumpkin covers most guests, but a local-favorite pie gives a holiday menu a story. How onsite teams could try it: keep pumpkin as the anchor, add your state's standout pie as a second slice, and offer whole pies for pre-order pickup.
Original source: Instacart ↗